How did a lawyer who took on big oil and won end up under house arrest?: I remember hearing over a year ago that charges against Chevron for polluting these people of Ecuador had been dropped. Even if they weren’t charged… it isn’t like the pollution was going to disappear, and it certainly wasn’t the Ecuadorian people that caused the pollution. I was appalled that Chevron was able to get away with this. And you know what really ticks me off? Chevron is a Canadian Company and our governments have never offered to step in to right this wrong.
“Chevron’s case,” said Donziger’s lawyer Andrew Frisch, “rested on the testimony of a witness who was paid over $1 million.” Frisch stated that Kaplan’s rulings “have been contradicted in whole or in part by 17 appellate judges in Ecuador and 10 in Canada, including unanimous decisions of the highest courts in both countries.”
Nevertheless, without a jury, Kaplan accepted Guerra’s testimony and found that Donziger had committed fraud. Finally, Kaplan ordered Donziger to turn over his computer and cellphone to Chevron. Since this order violated attorney-client confidentiality, Donziger refused until the court of appeals could decide the issue.
Kaplan charged Donziger with “criminal contempt” for refusing his order. However, the order and the contempt charge were so outrageous that the N.Y. prosecutor’s office refused to accept the case. Kaplan defied the state authorities and appointed a private law firm, Seward & Kissel—with commercial ties to Chevron—to act as prosecutor, which, in turn, ordered Donziger be placed under “pretrial home detention.”
How did a lawyer who took on big oil and won end up under house arrest?: I remember hearing over a year ago that charges against Chevron for polluting these people of Ecuador had been dropped. Even if they weren’t charged… it isn’t like the pollution was going to disappear, and it certainly wasn’t the Ecuadorian people that caused the pollution. I was appalled that Chevron was able to get away with this. And you know what really ticks me off? Chevron is a Canadian Company and our governments have never offered to step in to right this wrong.“Chevron’s case,” said Donziger’s lawyer Andrew Frisch, “rested on the testimony of a witness who was paid over $1 million.” Frisch stated that Kaplan’s rulings “have been contradicted in whole or in part by 17 appellate judges in Ecuador and 10 in Canada, including unanimous decisions of the highest courts in both countries.”Nevertheless, without a jury, Kaplan accepted Guerra’s testimony and found that Donziger had committed fraud. Finally, Kaplan ordered Donziger to turn over his computer and cellphone to Chevron. Since this order violated attorney-client confidentiality, Donziger refused until the court of appeals could decide the issue.Kaplan charged Donziger with “criminal contempt” for refusing his order. However, the order and the contempt charge were so outrageous that the N.Y. prosecutor’s office refused to accept the case. Kaplan defied the state authorities and appointed a private law firm, Seward & Kissel—with commercial ties to Chevron—to act as prosecutor, which, in turn, ordered Donziger be placed under “pretrial home detention.”Read More